Categories
Data & Analytics

Using Python & AWS To Extract WordPress API Data

In this post, I use popular Python modules & AWS managed serverless services to extract WordPress API data.

Table of Contents

Introduction

Last year, I tested my Python skills by analysing amazonwebshark’s MySQL database with Python. I could have done the same in 2024, but I wouldn’t have learned anything new and it felt a bit pointless. One of my YearCompass 2023-2024 goals is to build more, so I instead decided to create a data pipeline using popular Python modules & AWS services to extract my WordPress data using their API.

A data pipeline involves many aspects, which future posts will explore. This post focuses on extracting data from my WordPress database and storing it as flat files in AWS.

Firstly, I’ll discuss my architectural decisions for this part of the pipeline. Then I’ll examine the functions in my Python script that interact with AWS and perform data extraction. Finally, I’ll bring everything together and explain how it all works.

Architectural Decisions

In this section, I examine my architectural decisions and outline the pipeline’s processes.

Programming Language

My first decision concerned which programming language to use. I’m using Python here for several reasons:

  • I use Python at work and am always looking to refine my skills.
  • Several AWS services natively support Python.
  • Python SDKs like Boto3 and awswrangler support my use case.

Data Extraction

Next, I chose what data to extract from my WordPress MySQL database. I’m interested in the following tables, which are explained in greater detail in 2023’s Deep Dive post:

In November I migrated amazonwebshark to Hostinger, whose MySQL remote access policy requires an IP address. While this isn’t a problem locally, AWS is a different story. I’d either need an EC2 instance with a static IP, or a Lambda function with several networking components. These are time and money costs I’d prefer to avoid, so no calling the database.

Fortunately, WordPress has an API!

WordPress API

The WordPress REST API lets applications interact with WordPress sites by sending and receiving data as JSON objects. Public content like posts and comments are publicly accessible via the API, while private and password-protected content requires authentication.

While researching options, I stumbled across MiniOrange‘s Custom API for WordPress plugin. It has a simple interface and a good feature list:

Custom API for WordPress plugin allows you to create WordPress APIs / custom endpoints / REST APIs. You can Fetch / Modify / Create / Delete data with an easy-to-use graphical interface. You can also build custom APIs by writing custom SQL queries for your WP APIs.

https://plugins.miniorange.com/custom-api-for-wordpress

This meant I could start using it straight away!

The free plan lets users create as many endpoints as needed. But it also has a pretty vital limitation – API key authentication is only possible on their Premium plan. In the free plan, all endpoints are public!

Now let me be clear – this isn’t necessarily a problem. After all, the WordPress API is public! And my WordPress data doesn’t contain any PII or sensitive data. No – the risk I’m trying to address here isn’t a security one.

Public endpoints can be called by anyone or anything at any time. With WordPress, they have dedicated, optimised resources that auto-scale on demand. Whereas I have one Hostinger server that is doing every site process. Could it be DDoSed into oblivion by tons of API calls from bad actors? Do I want to find out?

As I’m using the plugin’s free tier here, I’ll mitigate my risks by:

  • Adding random strings to the endpoints to make them less guessable.
  • Not showing the endpoints in my script or this post.

So ok – how will I get the API endpoints then?

Parameters

Next, I need to decide how my script will get the endpoints to query and the S3 bucket name to store the results.

With previous scripts, I’ve used features like gitignore and dot sourcing to hide parameters I don’t want to expose. While this works, it isn’t ideal. Dot sourcing breaks if the file paths change, and even with gitignore any credentials are still hardcoded into the script locally.

A better approach is to use a process similar to a password manager, where an authenticated user or role can request and receive credentials using secure channels. AWS has two services for this requirement: AWS Secrets Manager and AWS Systems Manager Parameter Store.

Secrets Manager Vs Parameter Store

Secrets Manager is designed for managing and rotating sensitive information like database credentials, API keys, and other types of secrets. Conversely, Parameter Store is designed for storing configuration data, including plaintext or sensitive information, in a hierarchical structure.

I’m using Parameter Store here for two reasons:

Storage

Next, I need to decide where to store the API data. And I’m already using AWS for parameters, so I was always going to end up using S3. But what makes S3 an obvious fit here?

  • Integration: S3 is one of the oldest and most mature AWS services. It is well supported by both the Python SDK and other AWS services like EventBridge, Glue and Athena for processing and analysis.
  • Scalability: S3 will accept objects from a couple of bytes to terabytes in size (although if I’m generating terabytes of data here something is very wrong!). I can run my script at any time and as often as I want, and S3 will handle all the data it receives.
  • Cost: S3 won’t be entirely free here because I’ll be creating and accessing lots of data during testing. But even so, I expect it to cost me pence. I’m not keeping versions at this stage either, so my costs will only be for the current objects.

Much has been written about S3 over the years, so I’ll leave it at this.

Use Of Flat Files

Finally, let’s examine the decision to store flat files in the first place. The data is already in a database – why duplicate it?

Decoupling: Putting raw data into S3 at an early stage of the pipeline decouples the database at that point. Databases can become inaccessible, corrupted or restricted. The S3 data would be completely unaffected by these database issues, allowing the pipeline to persist with the available data.

Reduced Server Load: Storing data in S3 means the rest of the pipeline reads the S3 objects instead of the database tables. This reduces the Hostinger server’s load, letting it focus on transactional queries and site processes. S3 is almost serving as a read replica here.

Security: It is simpler for AWS services to access data stored in S3 than the same data stored on Hostinger’s server. AWS services accessing server data require MySQL credentials and a whitelisted IP. In contrast, AWS services accessing S3 data require…an IAM policy.

Architectural Diagram

This is an architectural diagram of the expected process:

  1. User triggers the Python function.
  2. Python interacts with AWS Python SDK.
  3. SDK calls Parameter Store for WordPress & S3 parameters. These are returned to Python via the SDK.
  4. Python calls WordPress API. WordPress API returns data.
  5. Python writes API data to S3 bucket via the SDK.

Setup & Config

I completed some local and cloud configurations before I started writing my Python script to extract WordPress API data. This section explores my laptop setup and AWS infrastructure.

Local Machine

I’m using Windows 10 and WSL version 2 to create a Linux environment with the Ubuntu 22.04.3 LTS distribution. I’m using Python 3.12, with a fresh Python virtual environment for installing my dependencies.

AWS Data Storage

I already have an S3 bucket for ingesting raw data, so that’s sorted. I made a wordpress-api prefix in that bucket to partition the uploaded data.

This bucket doesn’t have versioning enabled because it has a high object turnover. Versioning is unneeded and could get very expensive without a good lifecycle policy! While this would be simple to do, it’s a wasted effort at this point in the pipeline.

Another factor against versioning is that I can recreate S3 objects from the MySQL database. As objects are reproducible, there is no need for the delete protection offered by versioning.

AWS Parameters

I’m using Parameter Store to hold two parameters: my S3 bucket name and my WordPress API endpoints. Each of these uses a different parameter type.

The S3 bucket name is a simple string that uses the String Parameter Type. This is intended for blocks of text up to 4096 characters (4kb). The API endpoints are a collection of strings generated by the WordPress plugin. I use the StringList Parameter Type here, which is intended for comma-separated lists of values. This lets me store all the endpoints in a single parameter, optimising my code and reducing my AWS API calls.

Python Script

In this section, I examine the various parts of my Python script that will extract data from the WordPress API. This includes functions, methods and intended functionality.

Advisory

Before continuing I want to make something clear. This advisory is on my amazonwebshark artefacts GitHub repo, but it bears repeating here too:

Artefacts within this post have been created at a certain point in my learning journey. They do not represent best practices, may be poorly optimised or include unexpected bugs, and may become obsolete.

If I find better ways of doing these processes in future then I’ll link to or update posts where appropriate.

Logging

Firstly, I’ll sort out some logging.

The logging module is a core Python library, so I can import it without a pip install command. I then use logging‘s basicConfig function to set my desired parameters:

Python
logging.basicConfig(
    level=logging.INFO,
    format="%(asctime)s [%(levelname)s]: %(message)s",
    datefmt="%Y-%m-%d %H:%M:%S"
    )

level sets the logging level to start at. logging.INFO records information about events like authentications, conversions and confirmations.

format sets how the logs will appear in the console. Sections enclosed by % and ( )s are placeholders that will be formatted as strings. Other characters are printed as-is. Here, my logs will return as Date/Time [Log Level]: Log Message.

datefmt sets the date/time format for format‘s asctime using the same directives as time.strftime().

These settings will give me logs in the style of:

2024-01-11 09:44:39 [INFO]: Parameter found.
2024-01-11 09:44:39 [INFO]: API endpoints returned.
2024-01-11 09:44:39 [INFO]: Getting S3 parameter...
2024-01-11 09:44:39 [WARNING]: S3 parameter not found!

This lets me keep track of what stage Python is at when I extract WordPress API data.

boto3 Session

To call the AWS services I want to use, I need to create a boto3 session. This object represents a single connection to AWS, encapsulating options including the configuration settings and credentials. Without this, Python cannot access AWS Parameter Store, and so cannot extract WordPress API data.

To begin, I run pip install boto3 in the terminal. I then script the following:

Python
import logging
import boto3

session = boto3.Session()

This code snippet performs two new actions:

  • Imports the boto3 module
  • Instantiates an instance of the boto3 module’s Session class.

As Session has no arguments, it will use the first AWS credentials it finds. In AWS, these will be from the Lambda function’s IAM role. No problems there. But I have several AWS profiles on my laptop, and my default profile is for a different AWS account!

In response, I can set an AWS profile using VSCode’s launch.json debugging object. By adding "env": {"AWS_PROFILE": "{my_profile_name}"} to the end of the configurations list, I can specify which local AWS profile to use without altering the Python script itself:

JSON
{
	"version": "0.2.0",
    "configurations": [
        {
            "name": "Python: Current File",
            "type": "python",
            "request": "launch",
            "program": "${file}",
            "console": "integratedTerminal",
            "justMyCode": true,
            "env": {"AWS_PROFILE": "profile"}
        }
    ]
}

Functions

This section examines my Python functions that extract WordPress API data. Each function has an embedded GitHub Gist and an explanation of the arguments and processes.

Get Parameters Function

Firstly, I need to get my parameter values from AWS Parameter Store.

Here, I define a get_parameter_from_ssm function that expects two arguments:

  • ssm_client: the boto3 client used to contact AWS.
  • parameter_name: the name of the required parameter.

I use type hints to annotate parameter_name and the returned object type as strings. For a great introduction to type hints, take a look at this short video from AWS Mad Lad Matheus Guimaraes:

I then create a try except block containing a response object which uses the ssm_client.get_parameter function to try getting the requested parameter. If this fails, the AWS error is logged and a blank string is returned. The parameter value is returned if successful.

I am capturing the AWS exceptions using the botocore module because it provides access to the underlying error information returned by AWS services. When an AWS service operation fails, it usually returns an error response that includes details about what went wrong. botocore can access these responses programmatically and log more exception details than the Python default.

I now have two additional changes to my main script:

Python
import logging
import boto3
import botocore

session = boto3.Session()
client_ssm = session.client('ssm')
  • botocore needs to be imported, so I add import botocore to the script. I don’t need to install botocore because it was installed with boto3.
  • I need a Simple Systems Manager (SSM) client to interact with AWS Systems Manager Parameter Store. I create an instance of the SSM client using my existing session and assign it to client_ssm. I can now use client_ssm throughout my script.

Get Filename Function

Next, I want to get each API endpoint’s filename. The filename has some important uses:

  • Logging processes without using the full endpoint.
  • Creating S3 objects.

A typical endpoint has the schema https://site/endpointname_12345/. There are two challenges here:

  • Extracting the name from the string.
  • Removing the name’s random characters.

I define a get_filename_from_endpoint function, which expects an endpoint argument with a string type hint and returns a new string.

Firstly, my name_full variable uses the rsplit method to capture the substring I need, using forward slashes as separators. This converts https://site/endpointname_12345/ to endpointname_12345.

Next, my name_full_last_underscore_index variable uses the rfind method to find the last occurrence of the underscore character in the name_full string.

Finally, my name_partial variable uses slicing to extract a substring from the beginning of the name_full string up to (but not including) the index specified by name_full_last_underscore_index. This converts endpointname_12345 to endpointname.

If the function is unable to return a string, an exception is logged and a blank string is returned instead.

No new imports are needed here. So let’s move on!

Call WordPress API Function

My next function queries a given API endpoint and handles the response.

Here, I define a get_wordpress_api_json function that expects three arguments:

  • requests_session
  • api_url: the WordPress API URL with a string type hint.
  • api_call_timeout: the number of seconds to wait for a response before timing out.

requests.Session is a part of the Requests library, and creates a session object that persists across multiple requests. I can now use the same session throughout the script instead of constantly creating new ones.

I open a try except block and create a response object. requests.Session attempts to call the API URL. If the response status code is 200 OK then the response is returned as a raw JSON dictionary.

This function can fail in three ways:

  • The status code isn’t 200. While this includes 3xx, 4xx and 5xx codes, it also includes the other 2xx codes. This was deliberate, as any 2xx responses other than 200 are still unusual, and something I want to know about.
  • The API call times out.
  • Requests throws an exception.

In all cases, the function raises an exception and doesn’t proceed. This was a conscious choice, as an API call failure represents a critical and unrecoverable problem with the WordPress API that should ring alarm bells.

As I’m using the Requests module now, I need to run pip install requests in the terminal and add import requests to my script. I then create my requests session in the same way as my boto3 session.

I’m also now using json – another pre-installed core Python module ready for import:

Python
import logging
import json
import requests
import boto3
import botocore

session = boto3.Session()
client_ssm = session.client('ssm')
requests_session = requests.Session()

S3 Upload Function

Finally, I need to put my JSON data into S3

I define a put_s3_object function that expects four arguments:

  • s3_client: the boto3 client used to contact AWS.
  • bucket: the S3 bucket to create the new object in
  • name: the name to use for the new object
  • json_data: the data to upload

I give string type hints to the bucket, name and json_data arguments. This is especially important for json_data because of what I plan to do with it.

I open a try except block and try to use put_s3_object to upload the JSON data to S3. In this context:

  • Body is the JSON data I want to store.
  • Bucket is the S3 bucket name from AWS Parameter Store.
  • Key is the S3 object key, using an f-string that includes the name from my get_filename_from_endpoint function.

The JSON data is created by my get_wordpress_api_json function, which returns that data as a dictionary. Passing a dictionary to put_s3_object‘s Body argument will throw a parameter validation error because its type is invalid for the Body parameter. json_data‘s string type hint will help prevent this scenario.

Moving on, the S3 client’s put_object function attempts to upload the data to the S3 bucket’s wordpress-api prefix as a new JSON object. If this operation succeeds, the function returns True. If it fails, a botocore exception is logged and the function returns False.

While no new imports are needed, I do now need an S3 client alongside the SSM one to allow S3 interactions:

Python
session = boto3.Session()
client_ssm = session.client('ssm')
client_s3 = session.client('s3')
requests_session = requests.Session()

Script Body

This section examines the body of my Python script. I look at the script’s flow, the objects passed to the functions and the responses to successful and failed processes.

Variables

In addition to the imports and sessions already listed, I have some additions:

  • The S3 bucket and WordPress API Parameter Store names.
  • An api_call_timeout value for the WordPress API requests in seconds.
  • Three endpoint counts used for monitoring failures, successes and overall progress.
Python
# Parameter Names
parametername_s3bucket = '/s3/lakehouse/name/raw'
parametername_wordpressapi = '/wordpress/amazonwebshark/api/mysqlendpoints'

# Counters
api_call_timeout = 30
endpoint_count_all = 0
endpoint_count_failure = 0
endpoint_count_success = 0

Getting The Parameters

The first part of the script’s body handles getting the AWS parameters.

Firstly, I pass my SSM client and WordPress API parameter name to my get_parameter_from_ssm function.

If successful, the function returns a comma-separated string of API endpoints. I transform this string into a list using .split(",") and assign the list to api_endpoints_list. Otherwise, an empty string is returned.

This empty string is unchanged by .split(",") and is assigned to api_endpoints_list. This is why get_parameter_from_ssm returns a blank string if it hits an exception. split(",") has no issues with a blank string, but throws attribute errors with returns like False and None.

I then check if api_endpoints_list contains anything using if not any(api_endpoints_list). return ends the script execution if the list contains no values, otherwise the number of endpoints is recorded.

A similar process happens with the S3 bucket parameter. My get_parameter_from_ssm function is called with the same SSM client and the S3 parameter name. This time a simple string is returned, so no splitting is needed. This string is assigned to s3_bucket, and if it’s found to be empty then return ends the current execution.

If both api_endpoints_list and s3_bucket pass their tests, the script moves on to the next section.

Getting The Data

The second part of the script’s body handles getting data from the API endpoints.

Firstly, I open a for loop for each endpoint in api_endpoints_list. I pass each endpoint to my get_filename_from_endpoint function to get the name to use for logging and object creation. This name is assigned to object_name.

object_name is then checked. If found to be empty, the loop skips that endpoint to prevent any useless API calls and to preserve the existing S3 data. The failure counter increments by 1, and continue ends the current iteration of the for loop.

Once the name is parsed, my Requests session, timeout values and current API endpoint are passed to the get_wordpress_api_json function. This function returns a JSON dictionary that I assign to api_json. api_json is then checked and, if empty, skipped from the loop using continue.

Next, I need to transform the api_json dictionary object before an S3 upload attempt. If I pass api_json to S3’s put_object as is, the Body parameter throws a ParamValidationError because it can’t accept dictionaries. I use the json.dumps function to transform api_json to a JSON-formatted string and assign it to api_json_string, which put_object‘s Body parameter can accept.

I can now pass my S3 client, S3 bucket name, object_name and api_json_string to my put_s3_object function. This function’s output is assigned to ok, which is then checked and updates the success or failure counter as appropriate.

Once all APIs are processed, the loop ends and the final success and failure totals are logged.

Adding A Handler

Finally, I encapsulate the script’s body into a lambda_handler function. Handlers let AWS Lambda run invoked functions, so I’ll need one when I deploy my script to the cloud.

Resources

The full Python script has been checked into the amazonwebshark GitHub repo, available via the button below. Included is a requirements.txt file for the Python libraries used to extract the WordPress API data.

GitHub-BannerSmall

Summary

In this post, I used popular Python modules & AWS managed serverless services to extract WordPress API data.

I took a lot away from this! The script was a good opportunity to practise my Python skills and try out unfamiliar features like type hints, continue and requests.Session. Additionally, I made several revisions to control flows, logging and error handling that were triggered by writing this post. The script is clearer and faster as a result.

With the script complete, my next step will be deploying it to AWS Lambda and automating its execution. So keep an eye out for that! If this post has been useful, the button below has links for contact, socials, projects and sessions:

SharkLinkButton 1

Thanks for reading ~~^~~

Categories
Data & Analytics

1st Birthday MySQL Data Analysis With DBeaver & Python

In this post, I celebrate amazonwebshark’s 1st birthday with an analysis of my site’s MySQL data using DBeaver, Python and Matplotlib.

Table of Contents

Introduction

amazonwebshark is one year old today!

PXL 20221230 170232698 800600

To mark the occasion, I decided to examine the MySQL database that WordPress uses to run amazonwebshark, and see what it could tell me about the past twelve months.

In addition, I’ve been trying out DataCamp and have recently finished their Intermediate Python course. It introduced me to Matplotlib, and this post is a great chance to try out those new skills!

Timeline

I’ll start by answering a question. Why is amazonwebshark’s birthday on January 09 when my first post’s publication date is December 02 2021?

In response, here’s a brief timeline of how amazonwebshark came to be:

09 January 2022 was the first day that everything was fully live, so I view that as amazonwebshark’s birthday.

The three LinkedIn posts were added here on 19 January 2022, but without Introducing amazonwebshark.com they would never have left LinkedIn!

WordPress Database

In this section, I take a closer look at amazonwebshark’s MySQL database and the ways I can access it.

Database Schema

A WordPress site has lots to keep track of, like logins, plugins and posts. For this, it uses the MySQL database management system.

A standard WordPress installation creates twelve MySQL tables. WordPress describes them in its documentation, which includes this entity relationship diagram:

Additionally, DeliciousBrains have produced an Ultimate Developer’s Guide to the WordPress Database which gives a full account of each table’s columns and purpose.

SiteGround Portal Database Access

WordPress databases are usually accessed with phpMyAdmin – a free tool for MySQL admin over the Internet.

WPBeginner has a Beginner’s Guide To WordPress Database Management With phpMyAdmin, covering topics including restoring backups, optimisation and password resets.

While phpMyAdmin is great for basic maintenance, it’s not very convenient for data analysis:

  • There are no data tools like schema visualization or query plans.
  • It lacks scripting tools like IntelliSense or auto-complete.
  • Accessing it usually involves accessing the web host’s portal first.

Ideally, I’d prefer to access my database remotely using a SQL client instead. While this needs some additional config, SiteGround makes this very simple!

Remote Database Access

By default, SiteGround denies any remote access requests. Many people will never use this feature, so disabling it is a good security measure. Remote access is enabled in the SiteGround portal, which grants immediate remote access for specified IPs and hostnames.

After doing that, I created a new database user with read-only (SELECT) access to the MySQL database:

2023 01 01 SiteGroundMySQLPermissions

This isn’t strictly necessary, but the default user has unlimited access and violates the principle of least privilege in this situation.

The following SiteGround video demonstrates enabling remote access:

Analysis Tools

In this section, I examine the various tools I’ll use for amazonwebshark’s 1st birthday data analysis.

DBeaver

DBeaver is a free database tool and SQL client. It is multi-platform, open-source and supports a variety of databases including Microsoft SQL Server, Amazon Athena and MySQL.

DBeaver’s features include:

This VK Tech 360 video demonstrates connecting DBeaver to a local MySQL database:

mysql-connector-python

mysql-connector-python is a free Python driver for communicating with MySQL.

This Telusko video shows mysql-connector-python being used to access a local MySQL database:

mysql-connector-python is on PyPi and is installable via pip:

pip install mysql-connector-python

After mysql-connector-python is installed and imported, a connection to a MySQL database can be made using the mysql.connector.connect() function with the following arguments:

  • host: Hostname or IP address of the MySQL server.
  • database: MySQL database name.
  • user: User name used to authenticate with the MySQL server.
  • password: Password to authenticate the user with the MySQL server.

This opens a connection to the MySQL server and creates a connection object. I store this in the variable conn_mysql:

import mysql.connector

conn_mysql = mysql.connector.connect(
	host = var.MYSQL_HOST,
	database = var.MYSQL_DATABASE,
	user = var.MYSQL_USER,
	password = var.MYSQL_PASSWORD
	)

I have my credentials stored in a separate Python script that is imported as var. This means I can protect them via .gitignore until I get something better in place!

After that, I need a cursor for running my SQL queries. I create this using the cursor() method of my conn_mysql connection object and store the whole thing as cursor:

cursor = conn_mysql.cursor()

I’m now in a position to start running SQL queries from Python. I import a SQL query from my var script (in this case my Category query) and store it as query:

query = var.QUERY_CATEGORY

I then run my query using the execute() method. I get the results as a list of tuples using the fetchall() method, which I store as results:

cursor.execute(query)
results = cursor.fetchall()

Finally, I disconnect my cursor and MySQL connection with the close() method:

cursor.close()
conn_mysql.close()

Matplotlib

Matplotlib is a library for creating visualizations in Python. It can produce numerous plot types and has a large gallery of examples.

This BlondieBytes video shows a short demo of Matplotlib inside a Jupyter Notebook:

Matplotlib is on PyPi and is installable via pip:

pip install matplotlib

To view Matplotlib’s charts in Visual Studio Code I had to use an interactive window. Visual Studio Code has several options for this. Here I used the Run Current File In Interactive Window option, which needed the IPyKernel package to be installed in my Python virtual environment first.

Categories Analysis

In this section, I begin amazonwebshark’s 1st birthday data analysis by writing a SQL query for amazonwebshark’s categories and analysing the results with Python.

Categories Analysis: SQL Query

For my Category SQL query, I’ll be using the terms and term_taxonomy tables:

2023 01 07 WordPressTables

WordPress has a taxonomy system for content organization. Individual taxonomy items are called terms, and they are stored in the terms table. Terms for amazonwebshark include Data & Analytics and Security & Monitoring.

The term_taxonomy table links a term_id to a taxonomy, giving context for each term. Common taxonomies are category, post_tag and nav_menu.

If I join these tables on term_id then I can map terms to taxonomies. In the following query results, the first two columns are from terms and the rest are from term_taxonomy:

2023 01 07 DBeaverQuery

My final query keeps the join, cleans up terms.name, returns all categories with at least one use and orders the results by term_taxonomy.count and terms.name:

SELECT
	REPLACE (t.name, '&', '&') AS name,
	tt.count
FROM
	term_taxonomy AS tt
INNER JOIN terms AS t ON
	tt.term_id = t.term_id
WHERE
	tt.taxonomy = 'category'
	AND tt.count > 0
ORDER BY
	tt.count ASC ,
	t.name DESC
2023 01 04 DBeaverCategoryResults

In future, I’ll need to limit the results of this query to a specific time window. Here, I want all the results so no further filtering is needed.

Categories Analysis: Python Script

Currently, my results variable contains the results of the var.QUERY_CATEGORY SQL query. When I run print(results), I get this list of tuples:

[('Training & Community', 1), ('DevOps & Infrastructure', 1), ('AI & Machine Learning', 1), ('Internet Of Things & Robotics', 2), ('Architecture & Resilience', 2), ('Security & Monitoring', 3), ('Me', 4), ('Data & Analytics', 5), ('Developing & Application Integration', 8)]

So how do I turn this into a graph? Firstly, I need to split results up into what will be my X-axis and Y-axis. For this, I create two empty lists called name and count:

name = []
count = []

After that, I populate the lists by looping through result. For each tuple, the first item is appended to name and the second is appended to count:

for result in results:
    name.append(result[0])
    count.append(result[1])

When I print the lists now, name and count contain the names and counts from the SQL query in the same order as the original results:

print(f'name = {name}')
name = ['Training & Community', 'DevOps & Infrastructure', 'AI & Machine Learning', 'Internet Of Things & Robotics', 'Architecture & Resilience', 'Security & Monitoring', 'Me', 'Data & Analytics', 'Developing & Application Integration']
print(f'count = {count}')
count = [1, 1, 1, 2, 2, 3, 4, 5, 8]

I then use these lists with Matplotlib, imported as plt:

plt.bar(name, count)
plt.xlabel("category name")
plt.ylabel("category count")
plt.title("amazonwebshark categories")
plt.show()
  • bar sets the visual’s type as a bar chart. The X-axis is name and the Y-axis is count.
  • xlabel labels the X-axis as category name
  • ylabel labels the Y-axis as category count.
  • title names the chart as amazonwebshark categories
  • show shows the graph.

The following chart is produced:

sharkbirth category bar

However, the X-axis labels are unreadable. I can fix this by changing my script:

plt.barh(name, count)
plt.xlabel("count")
plt.ylabel("name")
plt.title("amazonwebshark categories")
plt.show()

I use barh to change the graph to a horizontal bar chart, and then swap the xlabel and ylabel strings around. This time the chart is far easier to read:

sharkbirth category barh

Tags Analysis

In this section, I continue amazonwebshark’s 1st birthday data analysis by writing a SQL query for amazonwebshark’s tags and analysing the results with Python.

Tags Analysis: SQL Query

My Tags SQL query is almost the same as my Categories one. This time, my WHERE clause is filtering on post_tag:

SELECT
	REPLACE (t.name, '&', '&') AS name,
	tt.count
FROM
	term_taxonomy AS tt
INNER JOIN terms t ON
	tt.term_id = t.term_id
WHERE
	tt.taxonomy = 'post_tag'
	AND tt.count > 0
ORDER BY
	tt.count ASC ,
	t.name DESC

There are more results this time. While I try to limit my use of categories, I’m currently using 44 tags:

2023 01 04 DBeaverTagsResults

Tags Analysis: Python Script

My Tags Python script is (also) almost the same as my Categories one. This time, the query variable has a different value:

query = var.QUERY_TAG

So print(results) returns a new list of tuples:

[('Running', 1), ('Read The Docs', 1), ('Raspberry Pi Zero', 1), ('Raspberry Pi 4', 1), ('Python: Pandas', 1), ('Python: NumPy', 1), ('Python: Boto3', 1), ('Presto', 1), ('Postman', 1), ('Microsoft Power BI', 1), ('Linux', 1), ('Gardening', 1), ('DNS', 1), ('AWS IoT Core', 1), ('Amazon RDS', 1), ('Amazon EventBridge', 1), ('Amazon EC2', 1), ('Amazon DynamoDB', 1), ('Agile', 1), ('Academia', 1), ('WordPress', 2), ('PowerShell', 2), ('OAuth2', 2), ('Microsoft SQL Server', 2), ('Microsoft Azure', 2), ('AWS Data Wrangler', 2), ('AWS CloudTrail', 2), ('Apache Parquet', 2), ('Amazon SNS', 2), ('Amazon Route53', 2), ('Amazon CloudWatch', 2), ('T-SQL Tuesday', 3), ('Strava', 3), ('Certifications', 3), ('Amazon Athena', 3), ('WordPrompt', 4), ('Project: iTunes Export Data Pipeline (2022-2023)', 4), ('Music', 4), ('GitHub', 4), ('AWS Billing And Cost Management', 4), ('Visual Studio Code', 5), ('Amazon S3', 5), ('Python', 6), ('Amazon Web Services', 16)]

Matplotlib uses these results to produce another horizontal bar chart with a new title:

plt.barh(name, count)
plt.xlabel("count")
plt.ylabel("name")
plt.title("amazonwebshark tags")
plt.show()

But this chart has a different problem – the Y-axis is unreadable because of the number of tags returned by my SQL query:

sharkbirth tag all

To fix this, I reduce the number of rows returned by changing my SQL WHERE clause from:

WHERE
	tt.taxonomy = 'post_tag'
	AND tt.count > 0

to:

WHERE
	tt.taxonomy = 'post_tag'
	AND tt.count > 2

This returns a smaller list of tuples:

[('T-SQL Tuesday', 3), ('Strava', 3), ('Certifications', 3), ('Amazon Athena', 3), ('WordPrompt', 4), ('Project: iTunes Export Data Pipeline (2022-2023)', 4), ('Music', 4), ('GitHub', 4), ('AWS Billing And Cost Management', 4), ('Visual Studio Code', 5), ('Amazon S3', 5), ('Python', 6), ('Amazon Web Services', 16)]

I then update the title to reflect the new results and use yticks to reduce the Y-axis label font size to 9:

plt.barh(name, count)
plt.xlabel("tag count")
plt.ylabel("tag name")
plt.title("amazonwebshark tags (most assignments)")
plt.yticks(fontsize = 9)
plt.show()

The chart is now more useful and easier to read:

sharkbirth tag most

Views Analysis

I also planned to analyse my post views here. But, as I mentioned in my last post, some of this data is missing! So any chart will be wrong.

I haven’t had time to look at this yet, so stay tuned!

Summary

In this post, I celebrated amazonwebshark’s 1st birthday with an analysis of my site’s MySQL data using DBeaver, Python and Matplotlib.

I had fun researching and writing this! It can be tricky to find a data source that isn’t contrived or overused. Having access to the amazonwebshark database gives me data that I’m personally invested in, and an opportunity to practise writing MySQL queries.

I’ve also been able to improve my Python, and meaningfully experiment with Matplotlib to get charts that will be useful going forward. For example, I used the very first Tags chart to prune some unneeded tags from my WordPress taxonomy.

If this post has been useful, please feel free to follow me on the following platforms for future updates:

Thanks for reading ~~^~~

Categories
Developing & Application Integration

Production Code Qualities

In this post, I respond to November 2022’s T-SQL Tuesday #156 Invitation and give my thoughts on some production code qualities.

tsql tuesday

Table of Contents

Introduction

This month, Tomáš Zíka’s T-SQL Tuesday invitation was as follows:

Which quality makes code production grade?

Please be as specific as possible with your examples and include your reasoning.

Good question!

In each section, I’ll use a different language. Firstly I’ll create a script, and then show a problem the script could encounter in production. Finally, I’ll show how a different approach can prevent that problem from occurring.

I’m limiting myself to three production code qualities to keep the post at a reasonable length, and so I can show some good examples.

Precision

In this section, I use T-SQL to show how precise code in production can save a data pipeline from unintended failure.

Setting The Scene

Consider the following SQL table:

USE [amazonwebshark]
GO

CREATE TABLE [2022].[sharkspecies](
	[shark_id] [int] IDENTITY(1,1) NOT NULL,
	[name_english] [varchar](100) NOT NULL,
	[name_scientific] [varchar](100) NOT NULL,
	[length_max_cm] [int] NULL,
	[url_source] [varchar](1000) NULL
)
GO

This table contains a list of sharks, courtesy of the Shark Foundation.

Now, let’s say that I have a data pipeline that uses data in amazonwebshark.2022.sharkspecies for transformations further down the pipeline.

No problem – I create a #tempsharks temp table and insert everything from amazonwebshark.2022.sharkspecies using SELECT *:

When this script runs in production, I get two tables with the same data:

2022 11 02 SQLResults1

What’s The Problem?

One day a new last_evaluated column is needed in the amazonwebshark.2022.sharkspecies table. I add the new column and backfill it with 2019:

ALTER TABLE [2022].sharkspecies
ADD last_evaluated INT DEFAULT 2019 WITH VALUES
GO

However, my script now fails when trying to insert data into #tempsharks:

2022 11 02 SQLResults2Sharp
(1 row affected)

(4 rows affected)

Msg 213, Level 16, State 1, Line 17
Column name or number of supplied values does not match table definition.

Completion time: 2022-11-02T18:00:43.5997476+00:00

#tempsharks has five columns but amazonwebshark.2022.sharkspecies now has six. My script is now trying to insert all six sharkspecies columns into the temp table, causing the msg 213 error.

Doing Things Differently

The solution here is to replace row 21’s SELECT * with the precise columns to insert from amazonwebshark.2022.sharkspecies:

While amazonwebshark.2022.sharkspecies now has six columns, my script is only inserting five of them into the temp table:

2022 11 02 SQLResults3Sharp

I can add the last_evaluated column into #tempsharks in future, but its absence in the temp table isn’t causing any immediate problems.

Works The Same In Other Environments

In this section, I use Python to show the value of production code that works the same in non-production.

Setting The Scene

Here I have a Python script that reads data from an Amazon S3 bucket using a boto3 session. I pass my AWS_ACCESSKEY and AWS_SECRET credentials in from a secrets manager, and create an s3bucket variable for the S3 bucket path:

When I deploy this script to my dev environment it works fine.

What’s The Problem?

When I deploy this script to production, s3bucket will still be s3://dev-bucket. The potential impact of this depends on the AWS environment setup:

Different AWS account for each environment:

  • dev-bucket doesn’t exist in Production. The script fails.

Same AWS account for all environments:

  • Production IAM roles might not have any permissions for dev-bucket. The script fails.
  • Production processes might start using a dev resource. The script succeeds but now data has unintentionally crossed environment boundaries.

Doing Things Differently

A solution here is to dynamically set the s3bucket variable based on the ID of the AWS account the script is running in.

I can get the AccountID using AWS STS. I’m already using boto3, so can use it to initiate an STS client with my AWS credentials.

STS then has a GetCallerIdentity action that returns the AWS AccountID linked to the AWS credentials. I capture this AccountID in an account_id variable, then use that to set s3bucket‘s value:

More details about get_caller_identity can be found in the AWS Boto3 documentation.

For bonus points, I can terminate the script if the AWS AccountID isn’t defined. This prevents undesirable states if the script is run in an unexpected account.

Speaking of which…

Prevents Undesirable States

In this section, I use PowerShell to demonstrate how to stop production code from doing unintended things.

Setting The Scene

In June I started writing a PowerShell script to upload lossless music files from my laptop to one of my S3 buckets.

I worked on it in stages. This made it easier to script and test the features I wanted. By the end of Version 1, I had a script that dot-sourced its variables and wrote everything in my local folder $ExternalLocalSource to my S3 bucket $ExternalS3BucketName:

#Load Variables Via Dot Sourcing
. .\EDMTracksLosslessS3Upload-Variables.ps1


#Upload File To S3
Write-S3Object -BucketName $ExternalS3BucketName -Folder $ExternalLocalSource -KeyPrefix $ExternalS3KeyPrefix -StorageClass $ExternalS3StorageClass

What’s The Problem?

NOTE: There were several problems with Version 1, all of which were fixed in Version 2. In the interests of simplicity, I’ll focus on a single one here.

In this script, Write-S3Object will upload everything in the local folder $ExternalLocalSource to the S3 bucket $ExternalS3BucketName.

Problem is, the $ExternalS3BucketName S3 bucket isn’t for everything! It should only contain lossless music files!

At best, Write-S3Object will upload everything in the local folder to S3 whether it’s music or not.

At worst, if the script is pointing at a different folder it will start uploading everything there instead! PowerShell commonly defaults to C:\Windows, so this could cause all kinds of problems.

Doing Things Differently

I decided to limit the extensions that the PowerShell script could upload.

Firstly, the script captures the extensions for each file in the local folder $ExternalLocalSource using Get-ChildItem and [System.IO.Path]::GetExtension:

$LocalSourceObjectFileExtensions = Get-ChildItem -Path $ExternalLocalSource | ForEach-Object -Process { [System.IO.Path]::GetExtension($_) }

Then it checks each extension using a ForEach loop. If an extension isn’t in the list, PowerShell reports this and terminates the script:

ForEach ($LocalSourceObjectFileExtension In $LocalSourceObjectFileExtensions) 

{
If ($LocalSourceObjectFileExtension -NotIn ".flac", ".wav", ".aif", ".aiff") 
{
Write-Output "Unacceptable $LocalSourceObjectFileExtension file found.  Exiting."
Start-Sleep -Seconds 10
Exit
}

So now, if I attempt to upload an unacceptable .log file, PowerShell raises an exception and terminates the script:

**********************
Transcript started, output file is C:\Files\EDMTracksLosslessS3Upload.log

Checking extensions are valid for each local file.
Unacceptable .log file found.  Exiting.
**********************

While an acceptable .flac file will produce this message:

**********************
Transcript started, output file is C:\Files\EDMTracksLosslessS3Upload.log

Checking extensions are valid for each local file.
Acceptable .flac file.
**********************

To see the code in full, as well as the other problems I solved, please check out my post from June.

Summary

In this post, I responded to November 2022’s T-SQL Tuesday #156 Invitation and gave my thoughts on some production code qualities. I gave examples of each quality and showed how they could save time and prevent unintended problems in a production environment.

Thanks to Tomáš for this month’s topic! My previous T-SQL Tuesday posts are here.

If this post has been useful, please feel free to follow me on the following platforms for future updates:

Thanks for reading ~~^~~